--- title: A Significant Hurdle for ESG Investors description: Thoughts on the growing and incredible gap between C-Suite and average worker pay at S&P 500 companies. image: https://blog.artifexfinancial.com/hubfs/ArtifexESG.png --- [![](https://blog.artifexfinancial.com/hs-fs/hubfs/artifex%20logo%20color%20copy.jpg?width=300&height=106&name=artifex%20logo%20color%20copy.jpg)](http://www.artifexfinancial.com) - [Home](http://www.artifexfinancial.com) - Personal Services - [Financial Planning](http://www.artifexfinancial.com/personal-financial-planning/-2-0) - [Wealth Management](http://www.artifexfinancial.com/wealth-management/-02) - [Business Services](http://www.artifexfinancial.com/biz-services) - [ESG / Impact](http://www.artifexfinancial.com/esg) - [About Us](http://www.artifexfinancial.com/about-us/-02) - [Doug Kinsey](http://www.artifexfinancial.com/dougkinsey2) - [Darren Harp](http://www.artifexfinancial.com/darrenharp2) - [Gerald Summers](http://www.artifexfinancial.com/jerrysummers2) - [Kevin O'Connor](http://www.artifexfinancial.com/kevinoconnor2) - [Alexander Browning](http://www.artifexfinancial.com/alexanderbrowning) - [Elizabeth Raby-Salinas](http://www.artifexfinancial.com/elizabethraby-salinas) - [Jansen Davidson](http://www.artifexfinancial.com/jansendavidson) - [Blog](https://blog.artifexfinancial.com) - [Contact](http://www.artifexfinancial.com/contact/) # A Significant Hurdle for ESG Investors Posted by Doug Kinsey - 11 August, 2021 - - - - - [mailto:?&subject=https://blog.artifexfinancial.com/a-significant-hurdle-for-esg-investors&body=https://blog.artifexfinancial.com/a-significant-hurdle-for-esg-investors](mailto:?&subject=https://blog.artifexfinancial.com/a-significant-hurdle-for-esg-investors&body=https://blog.artifexfinancial.com/a-significant-hurdle-for-esg-investors) ![header-picture](https://cdn2.hubspot.net/hubfs/685080/IMG-TurboSodium/Sodium%20v2/blog/woman-notebook-working-girl.png "header-picture") The Corporate Monarchy I've recently been doing some overall research on our ESG portfolios, and have spent some time in one of our evaluation tools, YourStake.org, which I use for secondary screening of equities and mutual funds.  This is a robust tool that allows us to look at various metrics related to Environmental, Social, and Governance benchmarks for individual holdings, including such things as Animal Exploitation; Bribery, Corruption, and Fraud Violations; CEO Pay to Average Worker Pay Ratios; Deforestation; Environmental Violations; Fossil Fuel Industry Exposure; Migrant Detention Involvement; Prison Industry Exposure; Toxic Air Pollution; and Board Diversity.  These are all areas that ESG investors tend to have preferences about, among others, and we screen for acceptable investments for each individual client who has an interest in such things. There's a lot of evaluation involved in understanding the various scores and the underlying data behind them, as well as a lot of nuances related to the extent of violations, causes, and whether or not it is an ongoing problem, or if the company/fund has taken steps to remedy them. As I reviewed the data, one element stands out when reviewing the companies in the S&P 500 - the ratio of CEO to average worker pay. For the vast majority of investors, this is typically overlooked.  Our culture in the U.S. tends to value skill and expertise, and many people feel that if a company is performing well, the pay of the CEO / Management is inconsequential.  And certainly, the industry characteristics need to be considered as well as many other factors when making a judgment about any of these metrics.  However, there is much evidence that the incomes of corporate leaders have far outpaced those of the average worker over the last few decades. According to Statista, average CEO pay has increased 940.3% since 1978, whereas the average worker pay increase over the same timeframe is 11.9%. ![Screen Shot 2021-08-11 at 12.11.13 PM](https://blog.artifexfinancial.com/hs-fs/hubfs/Screen%20Shot%202021-08-11%20at%2012.11.13%20PM.png?width=1924&name=Screen%20Shot%202021-08-11%20at%2012.11.13%20PM.png) [https://www.statista.com/chart/19036/ceo-and-private-sector-worker-compensation/](https://www.statista.com/chart/19036/ceo-and-private-sector-worker-compensation/) And at the top of the list of imbalance ratios, we have the following 8 companies, to give you a little perspective on the high end of CEO: Worker Pay. ![Screen Shot 2021-08-11 at 12.25.29 PM](https://blog.artifexfinancial.com/hs-fs/hubfs/Screen%20Shot%202021-08-11%20at%2012.25.29%20PM.png?width=1888&name=Screen%20Shot%202021-08-11%20at%2012.25.29%20PM.png) [https://www.statista.com/chart/25332/largest-ceo-to-worker-pay-ratios-at-s-p-500-companies/](https://www.statista.com/chart/25332/largest-ceo-to-worker-pay-ratios-at-s-p-500-companies/) I ran a report, and you can see the [output for yourself](https://blog.artifexfinancial.com/hubfs/YourStake%20ESG%20Metrics%20-%20S%26P%20500.pdf) if you are interested.  Any cell marked with a "1" on the report shows you a possible flag for exclusion for that particular metric.  Of all the companies in the S&P 500, the number flagged for possible exclusion is 435 out of 500 companies.  In other words, 87% or all the companies in the index have CEO to Average Worker Pay ratios that are of potential concern.   What does this mean for the average ESG investor, and ESG investing in general?  If you define worker pay equality as an issue for you, this situation certainly narrows the field of potential investments.  From the standpoint of the growing popularity of ESG investing, perhaps more attention to these rankings will encourage more shareholder pressure for companies to be more equitable in their pay structures, but until then, this is a significant problem for Wall Street and our corporate culture in the U.S. Even if you don't classify yourself as an ESG investor, this should still be a concern.  Governance decisions made by companies affect the returns to shareholders, and this is one marker as to how corporate culture can impact profitability and worker satisfaction, which certainly has an impact on corporate performance. That said, there's little chance of any significant attitude adjustments at our public corporations, (and public redistribution through higher taxation is not a viable solution) so for most investors, this will not be a factor in deciding whether or not to invest in a particular company.  But if it is meaningful to you, we have the tools to make an independent evaluation.  Just know that the ability to build a portfolio that focuses on "fairer" corporate compensation arrangements will be limited for the time being. --Doug Kinsey, CFP®, CIMA® Partner, Chief Investment Officer Interested in scoring your individual ESG preferences?  You can access a quick questionnaire [here.](https://www.yourstake.org/questionnaire/intro/doug-kinsey/)       Topics: [ESG](https://blog.artifexfinancial.com/topic/esg), [Corporate Governance](https://blog.artifexfinancial.com/topic/corporate-governance), [ESG Investing](https://blog.artifexfinancial.com/topic/esg-investing) --- ### Recent Posts By Doug Kinsey - 11 August, 2021 #### Don't Get Hooked: A Guide to Recognizing and Avoiding Phishing [![read more](https://cdn2.hubspot.net/hubfs/685080/IMG-TurboSodium/Sodium%20v2/blog/arrow-recent-blog-post.png "read more")](https://blog.artifexfinancial.com/dont-get-hooked-a-guide-to-recognizing-and-avoiding-phishing) By Doug Kinsey - 11 August, 2021 #### What's Going On With The Banks? [![read more](https://cdn2.hubspot.net/hubfs/685080/IMG-TurboSodium/Sodium%20v2/blog/arrow-recent-blog-post.png "read more")](https://blog.artifexfinancial.com/whats-going-on-with-the-banks) By Doug Kinsey - 11 August, 2021 #### Monthly Economic Update [![read more](https://cdn2.hubspot.net/hubfs/685080/IMG-TurboSodium/Sodium%20v2/blog/arrow-recent-blog-post.png "read more")](https://blog.artifexfinancial.com/monthly-economic-update) --- ## Welcome to the Artifex Intelliplan Blog ### Commentary on the world of finance, and other things We at Artifex believe in enhancing the wisdom of our clients and readers.  While most of our topics will be related to investments, personal finance, and the economy, we also endeavor to include thought-provoking commentary on topics that will help you expand your "mental models", as referred to by Charlie Munger and Warren Buffet. We want you to learn from us and others how to think logically and see the world through an informed lens. Some of our regular topics include: - Monthly "Savvy Cybersecurity" updates with tips to keep your data safe - Economic and market commentary - Financial planning and investment management best practices - Thoughts to improve your mindset and your life ### Subscribe to our Newsletter ### Recent Posts ### Posts by Topic - [Economy (31)](https://blog.artifexfinancial.com/topic/economy) - [Investments (19)](https://blog.artifexfinancial.com/topic/investments) - [markets (18)](https://blog.artifexfinancial.com/topic/markets) - [stock market (18)](https://blog.artifexfinancial.com/topic/stock-market) - [global markets (17)](https://blog.artifexfinancial.com/topic/global-markets) - [Market commentary (13)](https://blog.artifexfinancial.com/topic/market-commentary) - [Covid-19 (12)](https://blog.artifexfinancial.com/topic/covid-19) - [Coronavirus (11)](https://blog.artifexfinancial.com/topic/coronavirus) - [Economics (10)](https://blog.artifexfinancial.com/topic/economics) - [Financial Planning (8)](https://blog.artifexfinancial.com/topic/financial-planning) - [inflation (8)](https://blog.artifexfinancial.com/topic/inflation) - [bonds (7)](https://blog.artifexfinancial.com/topic/bonds) - [stocks (7)](https://blog.artifexfinancial.com/topic/stocks) - [tax planning (6)](https://blog.artifexfinancial.com/topic/tax-planning) - [Retirement Planning (5)](https://blog.artifexfinancial.com/topic/retirement-planning) - [commodities (4)](https://blog.artifexfinancial.com/topic/commodities) - [oil (4)](https://blog.artifexfinancial.com/topic/oil) - [retirement (4)](https://blog.artifexfinancial.com/topic/retirement) - [Business (3)](https://blog.artifexfinancial.com/topic/business) - [Business owners (3)](https://blog.artifexfinancial.com/topic/business-owners) - [CARES Act (3)](https://blog.artifexfinancial.com/topic/cares-act) - [Fed (3)](https://blog.artifexfinancial.com/topic/fed) - [Independence Day (3)](https://blog.artifexfinancial.com/topic/independence-day) - [Thanksgiving (3)](https://blog.artifexfinancial.com/topic/thanksgiving) - [interest rates (3)](https://blog.artifexfinancial.com/topic/interest-rates) - [tax (3)](https://blog.artifexfinancial.com/topic/tax) - [2021 (2)](https://blog.artifexfinancial.com/topic/2021) - [Artifex (2)](https://blog.artifexfinancial.com/topic/artifex) - [Fiduciary (2)](https://blog.artifexfinancial.com/topic/fiduciary) - [Goldman Sachs (2)](https://blog.artifexfinancial.com/topic/goldman-sachs) - [Hanukkah (2)](https://blog.artifexfinancial.com/topic/hanukkah) - [SBA (2)](https://blog.artifexfinancial.com/topic/sba) - [Tax Tips (2)](https://blog.artifexfinancial.com/topic/tax-tips) - [Taxes (2)](https://blog.artifexfinancial.com/topic/taxes) - [USA (2)](https://blog.artifexfinancial.com/topic/usa) - [advisor (2)](https://blog.artifexfinancial.com/topic/advisor) - [cryptocurrency (2)](https://blog.artifexfinancial.com/topic/cryptocurrency) - [decisions (2)](https://blog.artifexfinancial.com/topic/decisions) - [easter (2)](https://blog.artifexfinancial.com/topic/easter) - [labor day (2)](https://blog.artifexfinancial.com/topic/labor-day) - [merry christmas (2)](https://blog.artifexfinancial.com/topic/merry-christmas) - [non-fiduciary (2)](https://blog.artifexfinancial.com/topic/non-fiduciary) - [personal finance (2)](https://blog.artifexfinancial.com/topic/personal-finance) - [portfolio models (2)](https://blog.artifexfinancial.com/topic/portfolio-models) - [strategy (2)](https://blog.artifexfinancial.com/topic/strategy) - [trends (2)](https://blog.artifexfinancial.com/topic/trends) - [vaccine (2)](https://blog.artifexfinancial.com/topic/vaccine) - [2020 (1)](https://blog.artifexfinancial.com/topic/2020) - [Bitcoin (1)](https://blog.artifexfinancial.com/topic/bitcoin) - [Business planning (1)](https://blog.artifexfinancial.com/topic/business-planning) - [Coinbase (1)](https://blog.artifexfinancial.com/topic/coinbase) - [Corporate Governance (1)](https://blog.artifexfinancial.com/topic/corporate-governance) - [ESG (1)](https://blog.artifexfinancial.com/topic/esg) - [ESG Investing (1)](https://blog.artifexfinancial.com/topic/esg-investing) - [Edward Jones (1)](https://blog.artifexfinancial.com/topic/edward-jones) - [Election (1)](https://blog.artifexfinancial.com/topic/election) - [Estate Planning (1)](https://blog.artifexfinancial.com/topic/estate-planning) - [Fee-Only Financial Planning (1)](https://blog.artifexfinancial.com/topic/fee-only-financial-planning) - [Financial Happiness (1)](https://blog.artifexfinancial.com/topic/financial-happiness) - [Happy Holidays (1)](https://blog.artifexfinancial.com/topic/happy-holidays) - [Harvard (1)](https://blog.artifexfinancial.com/topic/harvard) - [Harvard Commencement (1)](https://blog.artifexfinancial.com/topic/harvard-commencement) - [Herbers & Co. (1)](https://blog.artifexfinancial.com/topic/herbers-co) - [Iran (1)](https://blog.artifexfinancial.com/topic/iran) - [Life (1)](https://blog.artifexfinancial.com/topic/life) - [Lou Gehrig (1)](https://blog.artifexfinancial.com/topic/lou-gehrig) - [Masters of Liberal Arts (1)](https://blog.artifexfinancial.com/topic/masters-of-liberal-arts) - [Merrill Lynch (1)](https://blog.artifexfinancial.com/topic/merrill-lynch) - [Morgan Stanley (1)](https://blog.artifexfinancial.com/topic/morgan-stanley) - [Northwestern Mutual (1)](https://blog.artifexfinancial.com/topic/northwestern-mutual) - [Outlook (1)](https://blog.artifexfinancial.com/topic/outlook) - [PPP Loans (1)](https://blog.artifexfinancial.com/topic/ppp-loans) - [Passover (1)](https://blog.artifexfinancial.com/topic/passover) - [Rosh Hashanah (1)](https://blog.artifexfinancial.com/topic/rosh-hashanah) - [Ukraine (1)](https://blog.artifexfinancial.com/topic/ukraine) - [World Events (1)](https://blog.artifexfinancial.com/topic/world-events) - [achievements (1)](https://blog.artifexfinancial.com/topic/achievements) - [april (1)](https://blog.artifexfinancial.com/topic/april) - [artificial intelligence (1)](https://blog.artifexfinancial.com/topic/artificial-intelligence) - [associates (1)](https://blog.artifexfinancial.com/topic/associates) - [behavioral finance (1)](https://blog.artifexfinancial.com/topic/behavioral-finance) - [blockchain (1)](https://blog.artifexfinancial.com/topic/blockchain) - [cybersecurity (1)](https://blog.artifexfinancial.com/topic/cybersecurity) - [education (1)](https://blog.artifexfinancial.com/topic/education) - [fraud (1)](https://blog.artifexfinancial.com/topic/fraud) - [intern (1)](https://blog.artifexfinancial.com/topic/intern) - [january (1)](https://blog.artifexfinancial.com/topic/january) - [judgment (1)](https://blog.artifexfinancial.com/topic/judgment) - [mutual funds (1)](https://blog.artifexfinancial.com/topic/mutual-funds) - [november (1)](https://blog.artifexfinancial.com/topic/november) - [pandemic (1)](https://blog.artifexfinancial.com/topic/pandemic) - [recession (1)](https://blog.artifexfinancial.com/topic/recession) - [review (1)](https://blog.artifexfinancial.com/topic/review) - [scam (1)](https://blog.artifexfinancial.com/topic/scam) - [separation from service (1)](https://blog.artifexfinancial.com/topic/separation-from-service) - [severance (1)](https://blog.artifexfinancial.com/topic/severance) - [social security (1)](https://blog.artifexfinancial.com/topic/social-security) - [supply chain (1)](https://blog.artifexfinancial.com/topic/supply-chain) - [tariffs (1)](https://blog.artifexfinancial.com/topic/tariffs) - [team members (1)](https://blog.artifexfinancial.com/topic/team-members) - [update (1)](https://blog.artifexfinancial.com/topic/update) - [wealth creation (1)](https://blog.artifexfinancial.com/topic/wealth-creation) - [worst jobs in the world (1)](https://blog.artifexfinancial.com/topic/worst-jobs-in-the-world) see all ### Blog Archive - [June 2020 (8)](https://blog.artifexfinancial.com/archive/2020/06) - [March 2020 (7)](https://blog.artifexfinancial.com/archive/2020/03) - [April 2020 (7)](https://blog.artifexfinancial.com/archive/2020/04) - [September 2020 (6)](https://blog.artifexfinancial.com/archive/2020/09) - [April 2022 (6)](https://blog.artifexfinancial.com/archive/2022/04) [![Get Your Free Whitepaper, "6 Failed Beliefs That Are Damaging Your Financial Well-Being"](https://no-cache.hubspot.com/cta/default/1557625/6d25c7f6-eb8d-4b12-9f90-5007a5fdb902.png)](https://cta-redirect.hubspot.com/cta/redirect/1557625/6d25c7f6-eb8d-4b12-9f90-5007a5fdb902) ## Get a Copy of our whitepaper ### "6 Failed Beliefs That Are Damaging Your Financial Health"   [![Get Your Free Whitepaper](https://no-cache.hubspot.com/cta/default/1557625/46ef55a5-f59d-4e30-9fb9-1d435af4e371.png)](https://cta-redirect.hubspot.com/cta/redirect/1557625/46ef55a5-f59d-4e30-9fb9-1d435af4e371) Sign up to receive our latest commentary and updates ### About us Artifex Financial Group is a fee-only wealth management firm that was founded in 2007 by Doug Kinsey, CFP®, AIFA®, CIMA® and Darren Harp, AIF®.  We focus on the financial planning, tax and investment needs of individuals and families in the central and southwest Ohio area.   We promise you straight talk, independent and objective advice, open access, the highest professional standards, and an excellent value for your money. Learn more [**here**](https://www.artifexfinancial.com/about-us/-02) ### Quick Links - [Home](http://www.artifexfinancial.com) - [Contact](http://www.artifexfinancial.com/contact/) - [About Us](http://www.artifexfinancial.com/about-us/-02) - [Blog](https://blog.artifexfinancial.com) - [Wealth Management](http://www.artifexfinancial.com/wealth-management/-02) - [Personal Financial Planning](http://www.artifexfinancial.com/personal-financial-planning/-2-0) - [Business Services](http://www.artifexfinancial.com/biz-services) - [Artifex ESG Impact Investing](http://www.artifexfinancial.com/esg) - [Free Financial Planning Tools](http://www.artifexfinancial.com/free-financial-planning-tools/1) - [Client Login](http://www.artifexfinancial.com/client-login/-0) - [Compliance](http://www.artifexfinancial.com/compliance/-0) ### Fresh from our blog   ![](https://blog.artifexfinancial.com/hs-fs/hubfs/rss-icon-vector-923565258_1027x1027.jpeg?width=83&name=rss-icon-vector-923565258_1027x1027.jpeg "rss-icon-vector-923565258_1027x1027.jpeg") ### Sign up to receive our blog posts [![Submit a Service Request](https://no-cache.hubspot.com/cta/default/1557625/3ebf5b97-1972-4b2d-a13c-31c05487493c.png)](https://cta-redirect.hubspot.com/cta/redirect/1557625/3ebf5b97-1972-4b2d-a13c-31c05487493c) [![Click for the BBB Business Review of this Financial Planning Consultants in Dayton OH](https://blog.artifexfinancial.com/hubfs/Images/blue-seal-200-42-artifexfinancialgroupllc-4430.png)](http://www.bbb.org/dayton/business-reviews/financial-planning-consultants/artifex-financial-group-in-dayton-oh-4430#sealclick)[![](https://blog.artifexfinancial.com/hubfs/Images/logoNAPFA.gif)](http://napfa.org)             [Privacy Statement and Legal Terms](https://blog.artifexfinancial.com/privacy/) | [Disclaimer](https://blog.artifexfinancial.com/disclaimer/) | [Compliance](https://www.artifexfinancial.com/compliance/-0) [FINRA](http://www.finra.org/) and [SIPC](http://www.sipc.org) © 2018 Artifex Financial Group